• Fri. Nov 27th, 2020

These Confederate statues were removed. But where did they go?

After the death of George Floyd in late May, more than 130 Confederate statues and tributes to divisive historical figures have come down in a flurry of protests, acts of vandalism and government decrees.

But no matter how and why the monuments were removed, most communities remain stuck in a common struggle: what to do with them.

A review by NBC News of monuments that were ripped down or are slated to be pulled from public spaces found that most governments and agencies with oversight have no clear road map for what will happen next, and have placed the statues and markers into storage for the foreseeable future.

In only about 35 of the cases were the monuments transported to new homes or were awaiting to be moved or were a pending location or owner determined. Most of those monuments were delivered to Confederate cemeteries or accepted by a museum, although a handful were slated for private properties, returned to local historical societies and organizations with ties to the statues, or in one case, sent to a historic battlefield in Virginia’s Shenandoah Valley.

At least three vandalized statues — one of an early 1900s politician in Nashville, Tennessee, and two at the state Capitol in Madison, Wisconsin — were expected to be repaired and returned to their original sites, local officials said.

An apparent lackluster response toward the monuments doesn’t surprise Sarah Beetham, the chair of liberal arts and an assistant professor of art history at the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts. She said some communities must wrestle with whether a statue is worth preserving if it is only going to be relegated to storage or was already damaged or weather-worn.

“It’s highly likely many of them will never be seen again,” she said.

In addition, Beetham said, many of the monuments weigh several tons and require cranes to haul them, so the cost of moving them could come at a hefty price for interested parties.

“Once you get them down on the ground and realize how big they are, you have a real problem on your hands,” she said. “Even if a museum has the space, they have to ask, ‘Will they crack the floorboards? Will there even be a way to move them inside?'”

July 11, 202008:21

The city of Newport News, Virginia, where a more than century-old Confederate monument will be taken down in the coming days, had reached out to five organizations, including local historical societies and museums, in the hopes that one of them would want it.

But one museum responded and said it was too big, city spokeswoman Kim Lee said. The monument, which is owned by the city, will have to go into storage.

“We thought there might be interest,” she said. “So we’re certainly willing to entertain offers and listen to anyone who wants it.”

The nearby city of Norfolk also had no takers for its Confederate statue, known as “Johnny Reb,” and officials said it would likely be installed this fall at a local cemetery.

In July, a new law in Virginia went into effect that requires 30 days’ public notice before a government body can vote to remove a Confederate war memorial. If successful, officials have another 30 days to offer the memorial to a museum, historical society, government or military battlefield.

Crews attach straps to the statue Confederate General J.E.B. Stuart on Monument Avenue on July 7, 2020, in Richmond, Va.Steve Helber / AP file

The legislation gives local governments more power in deciding whether to remove Confederate statues from public property. Those in opposition of removing monuments argue they affirm American history and consider them works of art, and say scrubbing them from view would only eradicate a sense of heritage and promote censorship.

According to the Southern Poverty Law Center, nearly 1,800 Confederate symbols are displayed on public lands. But since the killing of Floyd, a Black man who died after being restrained by Minneapolis police, almost 100 Confederate statues and symbols have been relocated or removed, while schools and other places have been renamed.

The sweeping changes are spurred by a larger demand for the nation to confront a long history of racism and oppression.

Virginia’s capital of Richmond has been a battleground for the monument debate after Gov. Ralph Northam, a Democrat, announced in June that the prominent statue of Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee would be taken down, along with four others depicting Confederate figures, from a two-mile stretch of Monument Avenue.

The monuments were the focus of intense protests and became gathering places where demonstrators clashed with police and rallied in the name of Floyd and others who’ve died in police encounters.

A lawsuit brought by several Monument Avenue property owners has blocked the Lee statue’s removal as the case continues through the courts next month. But that hasn’t stopped activists from using the graffitied statue as a backdrop to project images of Floyd, as well as civil rights icon Rep. John Lewis, who died in July.

The image of Rep. John Lewis, a pioneer of the civil rights movement and long-time member of the U.S. House of Representatives, is projected on the statue of Confederate General Robert E. Lee in Richmond on July 19.Jay Paul / Reuters

Some government agencies are using public task forces to determine what should happen to contentious monuments.

At Minnesota’s state Capitol in St. Paul, protesters in June used a rope to topple a nearly 90-year-old statue of Christopher Columbus — one of about 30 across the country of the Italian explorer that were either vandalized or removed in support of Indigenous people.

The Columbus statue’s unintended removal has forced a discussion on what monuments and artwork are most appropriate for the capitol grounds, and it could be another four to six months before a task force decides the next steps, said Paul Mandell, the executive secretary of the Capitol Area Architectural and Planning Board, which has oversight of the property.

“It’s not 1492 anymore, and we know a lot of things about Columbus now that wouldn’t merit him getting placed here,” Mandell said.

For now, he added, Columbus remains in storage.

In Boston, the city’s art commission is reviewing public testimony to help determine what to do with its Columbus statue, which is in storage after vandals decapitated it in June. Officials are looking at potentially restoring the head and neck, which was done after a similar beheading in 2006, although they continue to solicit public input before a formal decision is issued.

The expedited removal of monuments, particularly on courthouse and government grounds, is a beneficial step toward the nation’s healing, said Geoff Ward, a professor of African and African American studies at Washington University in St. Louis who has mapped out visual symbols of racism.

But, he worries that necessary conversations about racial injustice that people of color are asking for in their communities are failing to happen each time a statue is taken down.

“This is a familiar U.S. scenario,” Ward said, “seeking to quickly move on and declare matters settled rather than dealing with issues and really processing traumas.”