• Fri. Oct 30th, 2020

A Long History of Language That Incites and Demonizes

WASHINGTON — President Trump has seized on the response in the streets to police brutality against Black men and women to bolster his re-election campaign, employing provocative and sometimes incendiary language and images to incite his followers, demonize his opponents or both.

He has sought to conflate all protesters with the small minority of people who have looted stores, started fires and engaged in violence against police officers. He has blamed street unrest on Democratic mayors and governors and even former Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr., his fall challenger.

He has also repeatedly threatened to deploy federal forces. And especially since a man affiliated with a right-wing group was shot and killed in Portland, Ore., on Saturday night, he has seemed to encourage freelance action by his own supporters who have showed up as well in places like Kenosha, Wis., eager to counter the protesters and sometimes engaging in violence themselves.

Mr. Trump’s approach, intended to divert attention from the human and economic costs of the pandemic, is consistent with a career of combative politics that play to racial animosities, going back to his time in business.

Since becoming president, he has seemed to equate white supremacists marching to preserve a Confederate statue in Charlottesville, Va., in 2017 to the people who demonstrated against them. And in 2018, during the midterm congressional campaign, he repeatedly warned that caravans of would-be immigrants heading to the southern border posed a national threat, a topic he quickly dropped after the elections.

Here is a breakdown of how Mr. Trump has sought to fuel partisan passions to his benefit during the summer of unrest touched off by the police killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis and other similar episodes that followed:

Video

transcript

Trump Calls Protesters a ‘Disgrace’

President Trump delivered remarks at an airport hangar in Manchester, N.H., where he criticized Joseph R. Biden Jr. and the Democrats’ handling of the George Floyd protests.

You had to see last night in Washington. It was a disgrace. It was a disgrace that these people are representing the United States of America. It was a disgrace. Protesters, you know I say: “Protest this, your ass.” I don’t talk about my ass. [crowd cheering] They’re not protesters. Those aren’t protesters. Those are anarchists, they’re agitators, they’re rioters, they’re looters. They’re not, you know you say that, and some of the people, not all of them, but some of the people back there. “Oh, I — how dare you?” These are friendly protesters, right? Friendly protesters. [crowd jeering] They’re just looking for trouble. Has nothing to do with George Floyd, has nothing to do with anything. They don’t even know who George Floyd is.

Video player loading
President Trump delivered remarks at an airport hangar in Manchester, N.H., where he criticized Joseph R. Biden Jr. and the Democrats’ handling of the George Floyd protests.

While aides maintain that Mr. Trump respects peaceful protesters, he regularly lumps them with those who have engaged in violence, calling them anarchists and thugs who hate America and likening the demonstrations to mob rule. “Protesters, your ass,” he said at a rally in New Hampshire on Friday.

He has at times exaggerated the extent of the violence and falsely attributed it across the board to the Antifa anti-fascist movement, one of his favorite targets. Over the weekend, he even retweeted a message from the conservative One America News Network asserting that the protests were actually a well-organized effort to mount a coup against him.

Video

transcript

Portland Unrest Is ‘Road Map’ for Radical Left, Trump Says

At a news conference on Aug. 7, President Trump addressed the federal law enforcement response to protests against the police in Portland, Ore.

Portland is a disaster. It’s been a disaster for many, many years. Brave federal law enforcement officers single-handedly — the officers, they singlehandedly saved the federal courthouse in Portland from lawless rioters and agitators and anarchists. That’s what they are. You know, when you find Molotov cocktails in somebody’s knapsack, and they say, “No, I’m just here to have a good time.” These are really sick, disturbed people. The radical left’s agenda in action, Portland is their roadmap for America. If the radical left gets in, and they treat Joe Biden as a puppet. He’s merely a puppet. But if the radical left gets in, they look at Portland as a thing that they want. That’s what they want. Why, who knows? Doesn’t matter, it’s different thinking. But it’s a mess.

Video player loading
At a news conference on Aug. 7, President Trump addressed the federal law enforcement response to protests against the police in Portland, Ore.

While Mr. Trump condemned the killing of Mr. Floyd shortly after it happened and signed a largely symbolic executive order meant to encourage police training, the president has done little since then to address the concerns of many Americans horrified by that encounter and others. Instead, he has focused on defending the police, who he says have been unfairly smeared and should not have their funding cut. He has also pushed back against critics, calling Black Lives Matter “a symbol of hate.” Some of the protesters, he has said, “don’t even know who George Floyd is.”

Video

transcript

Trump Condemns Cities Run by Democrats

President Trump responded to the nationwide protests against police violence during the Republican National Convention on Aug. 27.

We have a situation where things are going on as they are today. We must never allow mob rule. We can never allow mob rule. [applause] In the strongest possible terms, the Republican Party condemns the rioting, looting, arson and violence we have seen in Democrat-run cities all — like Kenosha, Minneapolis, Portland, Chicago and New York, and many others — Democrat-run.

Video player loading
President Trump responded to the nationwide protests against police violence during the Republican National Convention on Aug. 27.

Mr. Trump has repeatedly blamed “weak” governors and mayors for unrest in “Democrat-led cities.” He has claimed that the turmoil represents what would happen in “Joe Biden’s America” if he is elected, even though it is happening in Donald Trump’s America.

“Without law enforcement, there is chaos,” he said at a White House news conference on Monday. “If the Democrats have that power, every city in this country could be another Portland.”

The president and his allies highlighted the issue as a signature theme of last week’s Republican National Convention and have sought to put Mr. Biden and other Democrats on the defensive by accusing them of not condemning violence, although in fact they have.

Video

transcript

Trump Claims Police Aren’t ‘Allowed to Do Their Job’

President Trump addressed the protests in Portland, Ore., while delivering remarks at the 2020 Council for National Policy Meeting in Arlington, Va., on Aug. 21.

Now Americans must rally to turn back the radical left, socialists and marxists, right here at home. And you see that when you see these people rioting in Portland where you see the anger, the craziness these people are crazy. They’re crazy. And we won’t let it go on much longer, by the way, because you know they’re supposed to police their own town. But we’re not going to let it go on much longer. [applause] Because at some point, we have to say, “OK, you’ve had enough time to police your town.” And by the way, they have good police. They have good — Portland has good police — but they’re not, again, they’re not allowed to do their job. I’m the only thing standing between the American dream and total anarchy, madness and chaos. And that’s what it is. I’m representing you. I’m just here.

Video player loading
President Trump addressed the protests in Portland, Ore., while delivering remarks at the 2020 Council for National Policy Meeting in Arlington, Va., on Aug. 21.

A running theme of Mr. Trump’s statements and Twitter messages is his eagerness to send in federal agents or the National Guard even though governors and mayors have resisted it. The local police, he says about various cities, “aren’t allowed to do their thing” but if troops were brought in, they could end the violence almost instantaneously. “We could fix Portland in, I would say, 45 minutes,” he said the other day.

Mr. Trump has gone so far as to claim that he is “the only thing standing between the American dream and total anarchy, madness and chaos.”

The National Guard in each state reports to the governor, not the president. Mr. Trump could use his power under the two-century-old Insurrection Act to federalize a state’s guard units over the objections of a governor, but he has been reluctant to do so.

Rather than call for calm, Mr. Trump has cheered on his own supporters to wade into the furor in the streets, setting up collisions that have led to even more violence. Kyle H. Rittenhouse, a 17-year-old who attended a Trump rally, showed up at a demonstration in Kenosha wielding a military-style rifle and was later charged with homicide after two protesters were shot to death.

On Monday, the president cast Mr. Rittenhouse’s alleged actions as self-defense. “He probably would have been killed,” Mr. Trump said.

Mr. Trump reposted a tweet in support of Mr. Rittenhouse over the weekend that called him “a good example of why I decided to vote for Trump.” The president also seemed to justify supporters who cruised through Portland firing paintballs and pepper spray at protesters (and at least one reporter), saying it “cannot be unexpected after 95 days of watching and incompetent Mayor admit that he has no idea what he is doing.”

Taylor Turner and Maya Blackstone contributed video research and production.